5 Signs Your Medical or Dental Practice Has Outgrown DIY Payroll

healthcare practice

Payroll for small healthcare practices comes with a unique set of challenges. Growth—whether rapid or steady is an exciting sign of success. However, with expansion comes complexity, particularly in terms of payroll and compliance.

If you're still relying on manual processes or entry-level software, it may be time to upgrade to a payroll solution built for growing medical and dental practices. Here’s how to tell if your current setup is holding your business back and what to do about it.

You’re Spending Too Much Time Running Payroll

Manual payroll can quickly become overwhelming as your team grows. Tools like QuickBooks may work for solo practitioners or offices with fewer than 10 employees, but they’re not built for practices with expanding headcounts and evolving staffing models.

If you're constantly entering timesheets, calculating taxes, and tracking hours manually, it’s a sign you’ve outgrown your current payroll process. The right healthcare payroll software can save valuable time, reduce errors, and free up your admin staff to focus on running and growing the practice.

You’re Worried About Compliance (Or Already Missed Something)

As your team grows, your legal responsibilities change. Once your practice reaches 50 or more full-time employees, you're required to comply with the Affordable Care Act (ACA), including offering health insurance and reporting coverage annually. You may also face new state-specific regulations around wage and hour laws, paid leave, and overtime.

It’s easy to miss a detail when you’re juggling hiring and expansion. But falling out of compliance can lead to fines, audits, and major disruptions. A scalable, compliant payroll system helps you stay ahead of the rules, without losing momentum.

Your Staff Wants Direct Deposit, Portals, and Pay Stub Access

Most employees expect direct deposit and digital self-service tools even in smaller offices. If your team is still receiving paper checks or asking how to access their pay stubs, W-2s, or benefits info, it’s time to modernize.

A secure employee portal not only improves satisfaction, but it also reduces questions, manual paperwork, and interruptions for your administrative team. Giving your employees access to their own payroll information is a small upgrade that delivers big benefits.

You’ve Added Locations or Changed Your Staffing Model

Growth often brings about operational shifts, such as new locations, remote staff, per-diem employees, or outsourced services like billing. If your practice has expanded across state lines, you may also be navigating multiple tax codes and labor laws.

Suddenly, a simple spreadsheet or basic accounting software isn’t enough. Managing multi-location payroll, varying schedules, and contractor classifications requires automation and built-in compliance tracking. A healthcare-specific payroll platform helps you stay organized and audit-ready.

You’re Still Using a One-Size-Fits-All Payroll Tool

Tools like QuickBooks or FreshBooks may work for freelancers or microbusinesses, but growing healthcare practices need more. Medical and dental offices face higher volumes of transactions, complex pay structures, and industry-specific compliance challenges.

From tracking hours for nursing staff to managing reimbursements and stipends, a one-size-fits-all solution won’t cut it. A tailored platform like ours offers the automation, customization, and support healthcare organizations need to thrive.

Growing pains are a good problem to have. But outgrowing your payroll system can create avoidable setbacks. Upgrade to a smarter, healthcare-ready solution and keep your practice moving forward.

Discover how Workforce PayHub supports medical and dental practices like yours.

Eric Jones
How Independent Medical and Dental Practices Can Avoid Payroll Mistakes
We're Ready To Talk Payroll

REQUEST CONSULATION